The Passion According to the Four Gospels — Answers (Week Five)

  1. Jesus cries out with a loud voice and then dies
    Mark records Jesus crying out with a loud voice and then immediately dying.
    Reference: Mark 15:37
    Comparisons:
    • Matthew also records a loud cry, framed alongside accompanying signs (Matthew 27:50).
    • Luke records Jesus’ final words of trust before His death (Luke 23:46).
    • John records Jesus’ final declaration, “It is finished,” emphasizing completion (John 19:30).

  2. The tearing of the Temple veil
    Luke places the tearing of the Temple veil before Jesus’ death. Matthew and Mark place the tearing after Jesus dies.
    References: Luke 23:45–46; Matthew 27:51; Mark 15:38
    Omission: John does not mention the veil.

  3. Additional signs at Jesus’ death
    Only Matthew records additional signs such as an earthquake and the opening of tombs.
    Reference: Matthew 27:51–53
    Omissions: Mark, Luke, and John do not record these phenomena.

  4. Joseph of Arimathea as a secret disciple
    John alone identifies Joseph of Arimathea as a secret disciple of Jesus.
    Reference: John 19:38
    Other descriptions:
    • Matthew describes him as a rich man and disciple (Matthew 27:57).
    • Mark emphasizes his courage in approaching Pilate (Mark 15:43).
    • Luke notes his goodness and dissent from the council’s decision (Luke 23:50–51).

  5. Pilate surprised at Jesus’ death
    Only Mark records Pilate expressing surprise that Jesus had already died.
    Reference: Mark 15:44

  6. Women observing the burial
    Matthew, Mark, and Luke record women observing where Jesus was laid.
    References: Matthew 27:61; Mark 15:47; Luke 23:55
    Notes:
    • Mark and Luke name specific women, including Mary Magdalene.
    • Matthew mentions women observing with fewer names.
    • John records the burial but does not emphasize women as witnesses to the location (John 19:38–42).

  7. Burial described with greatest detail
    John provides the most detailed burial account, noting linen cloths, spices, the presence of Nicodemus, and preparation according to Jewish burial customs.
    Reference: John 19:39–42